CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT
================================================================================

BOOK: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book set is a sweet holiday collection of Christmas at Rosie Hopkins' Sweetshop & Christmas ...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It includes delicious recipes for celebrating the holiday season...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The set features two novels full of romance, cheer, and hope for this magical time of year...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is a Scottish Romance Book Set...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It includes sweet treat recipes for celebrating the holiday season...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The collection features two romantic and festive tales set on a charming island off the coast of Sco...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: The Twelve Dogs of Christmas
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is a delightful novel about a Christmas transport of rescue puppies...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It is guaranteed to warm readers’ hearts...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The story is a charming Christmas tale of thawing hearts, escaping dogs, and finding home...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is a delightful holiday read and a sequel to the instant New York Times bestseller The Chri...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It is set in a charmingly narrow historic street with its Victorian grey stone buildings and warmly ...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The story is about lovely new possibilities that present themselves just as snow begins to fall and ...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: Christmas with the Queen
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is a heartwarming historical novel set in December 1952...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It is about the young Queen Elizabeth II finding the right words to continue the tradition of her la...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The story is about old friends unexpectedly reunited by the occasion of the royal Christmas at Sandr...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


SUMMARY: 0/15 reasons passed (0.0%)
OVERALL STATUS: FAIL

Citation validation failed: 0/15 passed (0.0%)

Citation Validation Summary: 0/15 passed

PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
================================================================================

OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 70%
STATUS: FAIL
BOOKS ANALYZED: 5

BOOK 1: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • AI analysis temporarily unavailable due to service overload

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Retry analysis when service is available

================================================================================

BOOK 2: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • AI analysis temporarily unavailable due to service overload

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Retry analysis when service is available

================================================================================

BOOK 3: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • AI analysis temporarily unavailable due to service overload

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Retry analysis when service is available

================================================================================

BOOK 4: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • AI analysis temporarily unavailable due to service overload

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Retry analysis when service is available

================================================================================

BOOK 5: "Christmas with the Queen"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
  Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • AI analysis temporarily unavailable due to service overload

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Retry analysis when service is available

================================================================================

SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
----------------------------------------
• AI analysis service is temporarily overloaded
• Using fallback analysis with neutral scores
• Error: [GoogleGenerativeAI Error]: Error fetching from https://generativelanguage.googleapis.com/v1beta/models/gemini-2.5-flash:generateContent: [429 Too Many Requests] You exceeded your current quota, please check your plan and billing details. For more information on this error, head to: https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/rate-limits. To monitor your current usage, head to: https://ai.dev/usage?tab=rate-limit. 
* Quota exceeded for metric: generativelanguage.googleapis.com/generate_content_free_tier_requests, limit: 10
Please retry in 46.110065019s. [{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.Help","links":[{"description":"Learn more about Gemini API quotas","url":"https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/rate-limits"}]},{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.QuotaFailure","violations":[{"quotaMetric":"generativelanguage.googleapis.com/generate_content_free_tier_requests","quotaId":"GenerateRequestsPerMinutePerProjectPerModel-FreeTier","quotaDimensions":{"location":"global","model":"gemini-2.5-flash"},"quotaValue":"10"}]},{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.RetryInfo","retryDelay":"46s"}]

OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
----------------------------------------
• Retry the analysis when Gemini API is less busy
• Consider running tests during off-peak hours
• Check Google AI status page for service updates

CARD CONTENT EXTRACTION SUMMARY
================================
Total Books: 5

BOOK 1:
  Title: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set
  Authors: Jenny Colgan
  Imprint: Avon
  Relevance Score: 100%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. The book set is a sweet holiday collection of Christmas at Rosie Hopkins' Sweetshop & Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It includes delicious recipes for celebrating the holiday season
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The set features two novels full of romance, cheer, and hope for this magical time of year
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 2:
  Title: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection
  Authors: Jenny Colgan
  Imprint: Avon
  Relevance Score: 100%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a Scottish Romance Book Set
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It includes sweet treat recipes for celebrating the holiday season
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The collection features two romantic and festive tales set on a charming island off the coast of Scotland
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 3:
  Title: The Twelve Dogs of Christmas
  Authors: Susan Wiggs
  Imprint: William Morrow
  Relevance Score: 100%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a delightful novel about a Christmas transport of rescue puppies
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It is guaranteed to warm readers’ hearts
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The story is a charming Christmas tale of thawing hearts, escaping dogs, and finding home
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 4:
  Title: Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop
  Authors: Jenny Colgan
  Imprint: Avon
  Relevance Score: 100%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a delightful holiday read and a sequel to the instant New York Times bestseller The Christmas Bookshop
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It is set in a charmingly narrow historic street with its Victorian grey stone buildings and warmly lit shop windows
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The story is about lovely new possibilities that present themselves just as snow begins to fall and the lights of Christmas blink on
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 5:
  Title: Christmas with the Queen
  Authors: Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
  Imprint: William Morrow Paperbacks
  Relevance Score: 100%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a heartwarming historical novel set in December 1952
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It is about the young Queen Elizabeth II finding the right words to continue the tradition of her late father’s Christmas Day radio broadcast
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The story is about old friends unexpectedly reunited by the occasion of the royal Christmas at Sandringham House in Norfolk
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---

CHAT DATA SUMMARY
================
Total Books: 5

BOOK 1:
  Title: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set
  Author: Jenny Colgan
  Publishing Date: OCT-03-2023
  Imprint: Avon
  Score: 100%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. The book set is a sweet holiday collection of Christmas at Rosie Hopkins' Sweetshop & Christmas at Little Beach Street Bakery
    2. It includes delicious recipes for celebrating the holiday season
    3. The set features two novels full of romance, cheer, and hope for this magical time of year
---
BOOK 2:
  Title: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection
  Author: Jenny Colgan
  Publishing Date: OCT-03-2023
  Imprint: Avon
  Score: 100%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a Scottish Romance Book Set
    2. It includes sweet treat recipes for celebrating the holiday season
    3. The collection features two romantic and festive tales set on a charming island off the coast of Scotland
---
BOOK 3:
  Title: The Twelve Dogs of Christmas
  Author: Susan Wiggs
  Publishing Date: OCT-17-2023
  Imprint: HarperCollins
  Score: 100%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a delightful novel about a Christmas transport of rescue puppies
    2. It is guaranteed to warm readers’ hearts
    3. The story is a charming Christmas tale of thawing hearts, escaping dogs, and finding home
---
BOOK 4:
  Title: Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop
  Author: Jenny Colgan
  Publishing Date: OCT-10-2023
  Imprint: Avon
  Score: 100%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a delightful holiday read and a sequel to the instant New York Times bestseller The Christmas Bookshop
    2. It is set in a charmingly narrow historic street with its Victorian grey stone buildings and warmly lit shop windows
    3. The story is about lovely new possibilities that present themselves just as snow begins to fall and the lights of Christmas blink on
---
BOOK 5:
  Title: Christmas with the Queen
  Author: Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
  Publishing Date: NOV-19-2024
  Imprint: William Morrow Paperbacks
  Score: 100%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. The book is a heartwarming historical novel set in December 1952
    2. It is about the young Queen Elizabeth II finding the right words to continue the tradition of her late father’s Christmas Day radio broadcast
    3. The story is about old friends unexpectedly reunited by the occasion of the royal Christmas at Sandringham House in Norfolk
---

BOOK TITLES VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 5 | PASSED: 5 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set
  Expected: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set
---
BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection
  Expected: Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection
---
BOOK: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: The Twelve Dogs of Christmas
  Expected: The Twelve Dogs of Christmas
---
BOOK: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop
  Expected: Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop
---
BOOK: "Christmas with the Queen"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Christmas with the Queen
  Expected: Christmas with the Queen
---

AUTHORS VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 5 | PASSED: 5 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Jenny Colgan
  Expected: Jenny Colgan
---
BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Jenny Colgan
  Expected: Jenny Colgan
---
BOOK: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Susan Wiggs
  Expected: Susan Wiggs
---
BOOK: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Jenny Colgan
  Expected: Jenny Colgan
---
BOOK: "Christmas with the Queen"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
  Expected: Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
---

RELEVANCE SCORES VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 5 | PASSED: 5 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 100
  Expected: 100%
---
BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 100
  Expected: 100%
---
BOOK: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 100
  Expected: 100%
---
BOOK: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 100
  Expected: 100%
---
BOOK: "Christmas with the Queen"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 100
  Expected: 100%
---

WHY MATCH REASONS VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 5 | PASSED: 5 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---
BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---
BOOK: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---
BOOK: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---
BOOK: "Christmas with the Queen"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---

COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 5 | PASSED: 5 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "Christmas with the Queen"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---

=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification ===
[3:43:49 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[3:43:50 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[3:43:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking on mode selection dropdown
[3:43:53 PM] ✅ Mode selection dropdown clicked successfully
[3:43:53 PM] ℹ️ Checking visibility of mode: BookGenieQA
[3:43:53 PM] ✅ Mode "BookGenieQA" is visible
[3:43:53 PM] ℹ️ Selecting mode: BookGenieQA
[3:43:53 PM] ✅ Mode "BookGenieQA" selected successfully
[3:43:55 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for mode transition to complete
[3:43:58 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:44:28 PM] ⚠ ⚠Book Genie mode did not loaded
[3:44:28 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:44:28 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[3:44:28 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[3:44:28 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:44:29 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[3:44:29 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:44:29 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[3:44:29 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[3:44:29 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[3:44:29 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[3:44:31 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[3:44:31 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[3:44:32 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[3:44:32 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Checking for "None of the above, just" option...
[3:44:32 PM] ℹ️ ✓ "None of the above, just" option found - looking for sibling span to click
[3:44:32 PM] ℹ️ ✓ Found clickable span - preparing to click
[3:44:32 PM] ℹ️ Clicking on span with text: "+Search through the HarperCollins book catalog for 5 books on christmas"
[3:44:33 PM] ✅ ✅ Clicked on "None of the above, just" option span
[3:44:33 PM] ℹ️ ⏳ Waiting for AI to process "None of the above, just" selection...
[3:44:34 PM] ℹ️ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared after "None of the above, just" selection
[3:45:33 PM] ✅ ✅ AI thinking completed after "None of the above, just" selection
[3:45:39 PM] ✅ ✅ "None of the above, just" handling completed successfully
[3:45:39 PM] 📊 "None of the above" option was handled successfully
[3:45:39 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 3924 characters
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Question Type:  Book Metadata — AnalyzedWatch Me WorkLet me connect the dots for you...Retrieving Re...
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 31212 characters
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 1. "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 2. "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 3. "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 4. "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas with the Queen" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ Extracted 5 books from response
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Saving 5 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Creating test_results directory
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ test_results directory created
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 5 books to Excel format
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 18.95 KB
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (5 books) for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" vs expected: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" vs expected: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" vs expected: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 4: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" vs expected: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 4 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Book 4 validation completed
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 5: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas with the Queen" vs expected: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 100% vs expected: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 100% (expected 100%)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ PERFECT SCORE GAP VALIDATION: Book has 100% score and no gap mentioned
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 5 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Book 5 validation completed
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books passed
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 31212 characters
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[3:45:42 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 1. "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 2. "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 3. "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 4. "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas with the Queen" - Score: 100%%
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[3:45:42 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 100%
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found 11 total accordion sections
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "4. Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "5. Christmas with the Queen"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Processing 5 individual book sections
[3:45:42 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:42 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:45 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:45 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:48 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:48 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:48 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:48 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:50 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:45:50 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - 0 citations extracted
[3:45:50 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:50 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:53 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:53 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:56 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:56 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:56 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:56 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:58 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:45:58 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - 0 citations extracted
[3:45:58 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:45:58 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:01 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:01 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:04 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:04 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:04 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:04 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:05 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:05 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - 0 citations extracted
[3:46:05 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 4: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:05 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:08 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:08 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:11 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:12 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:12 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:12 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:13 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:13 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - 0 citations extracted
[3:46:13 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 5: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:13 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:16 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:16 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:19 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:19 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:19 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:19 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:21 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:46:21 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas with the Queen" - 0 citations extracted
[3:46:21 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 5 books
[3:46:21 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[3:46:21 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[3:46:21 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:46:21 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:46:23 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:23 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:23 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:46:30 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:30 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:30 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:46:34 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:34 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:34 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:46:34 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:46:38 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:38 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:38 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:46:38 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:38 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:38 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:46:39 PM] ❌    ❌ "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:39 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:39 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:46:39 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:46:45 PM] ❌    ❌ "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:45 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:45 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:46:52 PM] ❌    ❌ "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:52 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:52 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:46:56 PM] ❌    ❌ "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:46:56 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:46:56 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:46:56 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:47:00 PM] ❌    ❌ "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:00 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:00 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:47:01 PM] ❌    ❌ "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:01 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:01 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:47:04 PM] ❌    ❌ "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:04 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:04 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:04 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:47:05 PM] ❌    ❌ "Christmas with the Queen" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:05 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:47:05 PM] ❌    ❌ "Christmas with the Queen" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:05 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:47:05 PM] ❌    ❌ "Christmas with the Queen" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:47:05 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:47:05 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 0/15 passed (0.0%)
[3:47:05 PM] ❌ 💥 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[3:47:05 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 0/15 reasons passed
[3:47:05 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[3:47:05 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 0/15 (0.0%)
[3:47:05 PM] ❌ ❌ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED - Only 0.0% of reasons match citations (required: 80%)
[3:47:05 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[3:47:05 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 15 reasons
[3:47:05 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[3:47:05 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[3:47:05 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[3:47:06 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 10032
[3:47:06 PM] 📊 Database contains 10032 books
[3:47:06 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 10032 >= 10032
[3:47:06 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/5: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:47:06 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" → "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/5: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:47:06 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:47:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" → "Land"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/5: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:47:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" → "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 4/5: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:47:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" → "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 5/5: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas with the Queen" → "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:07 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books found in database
[3:47:07 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[3:47:07 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[3:47:07 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[3:47:07 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[3:47:13 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ GEMINI VALIDATION: Using fallback analysis due to API issues
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ Overall Score: 70% (Fallback)
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set" - Score: 70%
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    - Retry analysis when service is available
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection" - Score: 70%
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    - Retry analysis when service is available
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas" - Score: 70%
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    - Retry analysis when service is available
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop" - Score: 70%
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    - Retry analysis when service is available
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas with the Queen" - Score: 70%
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Why Match Explanations: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 70% - Analysis unavailable - API error
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    - Retry analysis when service is available
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    • AI analysis service is temporarily overloaded
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    • Using fallback analysis with neutral scores
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️    • Error: [GoogleGenerativeAI Error]: Error fetching from https://generativelanguage.googleapis.com/v1beta/models/gemini-2.5-flash:generateContent: [429 Too Many Requests] You exceeded your current quota, please check your plan and billing details. For more information on this error, head to: https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/rate-limits. To monitor your current usage, head to: https://ai.dev/usage?tab=rate-limit. 
* Quota exceeded for metric: generativelanguage.googleapis.com/generate_content_free_tier_requests, limit: 10
Please retry in 46.110065019s. [{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.Help","links":[{"description":"Learn more about Gemini API quotas","url":"https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/rate-limits"}]},{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.QuotaFailure","violations":[{"quotaMetric":"generativelanguage.googleapis.com/generate_content_free_tier_requests","quotaId":"GenerateRequestsPerMinutePerProjectPerModel-FreeTier","quotaDimensions":{"location":"global","model":"gemini-2.5-flash"},"quotaValue":"10"}]},{"@type":"type.googleapis.com/google.rpc.RetryInfo","retryDelay":"46s"}]
[3:47:13 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI AI VALIDATION FAILED: 70% relevance score (required: 80%)
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ Continuing execution due to soft assertion...
[3:47:13 PM] 📋 🔍 CHECKING FOR BOOK CARDS
[3:47:13 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for book cards to be visible
[3:47:13 PM] ✅ ✅ Found 5 book cards
[3:47:14 PM] 📋 📖 EXTRACTING DETAILED CARD CONTENT
[3:47:14 PM] ℹ️ Locating all book card containers
[3:47:14 PM] ℹ️ Found 5 book cards
[3:47:14 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 1/5
[3:47:15 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 1
[3:47:15 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 1
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:47:17 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:47:17 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 1 (after clicking citations)
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️ Card 1 HTML length: 12077 chars
[3:47:17 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 1 content extracted: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Jenny Colgan
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: Avon
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 100
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:47:17 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:17 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 2/5
[3:47:18 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 2
[3:47:18 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 2
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:47:20 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:47:20 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 2 (after clicking citations)
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️ Card 2 HTML length: 12174 chars
[3:47:20 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 2 content extracted: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Jenny Colgan
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: Avon
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 100
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:47:20 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:20 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 3/5
[3:47:21 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 3
[3:47:21 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 3
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:47:23 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:47:23 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 3 (after clicking citations)
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️ Card 3 HTML length: 12065 chars
[3:47:23 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 3 content extracted: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Susan Wiggs
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: William Morrow
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 100
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:47:23 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:23 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 4/5
[3:47:24 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 4
[3:47:24 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 4
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:47:26 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:47:26 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 4 (after clicking citations)
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️ Card 4 HTML length: 11462 chars
[3:47:26 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 4 content extracted: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Jenny Colgan
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: Avon
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 100
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:47:26 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:26 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 5/5
[3:47:27 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 5
[3:47:27 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 5
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:47:29 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:47:29 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 5 (after clicking citations)
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Card 5 HTML length: 12068 chars
[3:47:29 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 5 content extracted: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: William Morrow Paperbacks
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 100
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:47:29 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted content from 5/5 book cards
[3:47:29 PM] 📋 💬 EXTRACTING EXPECTED DATA FROM CHAT PANEL
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Locating left-side chat panel
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Verifying all sections are expanded...
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Found 5 book sections to expand
[3:47:29 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 1
[3:47:30 PM] ℹ️ "Why this book is the match" section for book 1 is already expanded
[3:47:30 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 2
[3:47:31 PM] ℹ️ "Why this book is the match" section for book 2 is already expanded
[3:47:31 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 3
[3:47:33 PM] ℹ️ "Why this book is the match" section for book 3 is already expanded
[3:47:33 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 4
[3:47:34 PM] ℹ️ "Why this book is the match" section for book 4 is already expanded
[3:47:34 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 5
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ "Why this book is the match" section for book 5 is already expanded
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ All chat sections expanded successfully
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from chat panel
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Chat HTML content extracted - Length: 19317 characters
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract expected book data using BookExtractor
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Book Set"
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book set is a sweet holiday collection of Christmas at Rosie Hopkins' Sweets..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It includes delicious recipes for celebrating the holiday season..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The set features two novels full of romance, cheer, and hope for this magical ti..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "Jenny Colgan’s Christmas Island Collection"
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book is a Scottish Romance Book Set..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It includes sweet treat recipes for celebrating the holiday season..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The collection features two romantic and festive tales set on a charming island ..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "The Twelve Dogs of Christmas"
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book is a delightful novel about a Christmas transport of rescue puppies..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It is guaranteed to warm readers’ hearts..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The story is a charming Christmas tale of thawing hearts, escaping dogs, and fin..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "Midnight at the Christmas Bookshop"
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book is a delightful holiday read and a sequel to the instant New York Times..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It is set in a charmingly narrow historic street with its Victorian grey stone b..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The story is about lovely new possibilities that present themselves just as snow..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "Christmas with the Queen"
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book is a heartwarming historical novel set in December 1952..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It is about the young Queen Elizabeth II finding the right words to continue the..."
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The story is about old friends unexpectedly reunited by the occasion of the roya..."
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED EXPECTED DATA FROM CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ℹ️ Found 5 books in chat panel
[3:47:35 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK TITLES AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL BOOK TITLES VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] 📋 👥 VALIDATING AUTHORS AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL AUTHORS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] 📋 📊 VALIDATING RELEVANCE SCORES AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL RELEVANCE SCORES VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING WHY MATCH REASONS AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL WHY MATCH REASONS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] 📋 🏆 COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION AGAINST CHAT
[3:47:35 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATIONS PASSED AGAINST CHAT
=== END LOGS ===

CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT
================================================================================

BOOK: A+ Parenting
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book includes recommended books...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It categorizes books by the earliest age...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book suggests that older children and even adults can profit from reading books...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 4: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It emphasizes the importance of the quality of books...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: A Christmas Carol
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It is a classic story suitable for children, with an interest age ranging from 6 to 10...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is a coloring activity book...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Classics...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


BOOK: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
------------------------------------------------------------
❌ Reason 1: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is categorized under JUVENILE FICTION...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Family / Orphans & Foster Homes...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book is also listed under JUVENILE FICTION: Humorous Stories...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"

❌ Reason 4: FAIL (0%)
   📝 Reason: The book has an interest age from 8 to 12 years...
   📚 Citation: No citation found...
   ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"


SUMMARY: 0/11 reasons passed (0.0%)
OVERALL STATUS: FAIL

Citation validation failed: 0/11 passed (0.0%)

Citation Validation Summary: 0/11 passed

PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
================================================================================

OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 75%
STATUS: FAIL
BOOKS ANALYZED: 3

BOOK 1: "A+ Parenting"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 65%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 90% - Author 'Eva Moskowitz' is clearly identified and relevant to the parenting book's content.
  Publishing Date: 90% - The publishing date 'OCT-24-2023' is recent and appropriate for a parenting guide, suggesting up-to-date advice.
  Why Match Explanations: 80% - The explanations accurately describe why this specific book is relevant to the *topic* of children's books (it recommends and categorizes them). However, it does not directly suggest a book *for* children, which is the primary intent of the query.
  Relevance Scores: 80% - The 95% relevance score is high given the book is a parenting guide and not a direct book for children. However, the 'Gap' explanation properly justifies *why* the score is not 100% by clarifying its indirect nature, which is good justification for its *own* given score, even if the score itself is high for the query.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This book, 'A+ Parenting,' is a significant departure from the query's direct intent ('Suggest 3 books for children'). It is a meta-book about selecting children's books, rather than a book *for* children to read.
  • While the 'Why Match' explanation and 'Gap' effectively communicate the book's content and its indirect relevance, the overall choice is a weak fulfillment of the explicit request for books children would read.
  • The author and publishing date are complete and accurate for this specific parenting book.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Prioritize direct children's books that children would read themselves for this query.
  • If a 'meta' book (like a parenting guide about children's books) is suggested, the relevance score should be significantly lower or the rationale for its inclusion as a 'book for children' needs stronger justification, perhaps by interpreting the query more broadly.

================================================================================

BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 95%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 100% - Author 'Charles Dickens' is clearly identified, highly renowned, and relevant for a classic children's adaptation.
  Publishing Date: 95% - The publishing date 'JUN-08-2010' is appropriate for a modern edition or adaptation of a classic story, ensuring its contemporary availability.
  Why Match Explanations: 100% - The explanations are excellent and directly justify the book's suitability: 'classic story suitable for children,' 'interest age 6 to 10,' 'coloring activity book,' and 'JUVENILE FICTION: Classics.' These are strong reasons for a direct match.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 92% relevance score is well-justified by the strong reasons provided. The lack of a 'Gap' explanation further indicates its direct and appropriate fit for the query.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This book is an excellent and direct match for the query 'Suggest 3 books for children.'
  • All provided information (Author, Publishing Date, Why Match explanations) is complete, accurate, and highly relevant, clearly demonstrating its suitability for children.
  • The description of it being a 'coloring activity book' further enhances its appeal to the target audience.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • No significant improvements are needed for this book selection; it perfectly addresses the query.

================================================================================

BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 70%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 0% - Author information is entirely missing from the provided analysis text for this book.
  Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is entirely missing from the provided analysis text for this book.
  Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are strong and directly justify its suitability: categorized under 'JUVENILE FICTION' (including specific sub-genres) and having an 'interest age from 8 to 12 years.' These are clear indicators for children's literature.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 90% relevance score is appropriately justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which acknowledges elements of 'horror' and 'nefarious plots' that might not suit all children. This demonstrates a nuanced understanding of children's literature suitability.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This book is a highly relevant and direct suggestion for the query 'Suggest 3 books for children,' fitting squarely within juvenile fiction with an appropriate age range.
  • However, the complete absence of Author and Publishing Date from the provided analysis text is a critical oversight, significantly reducing the completeness and utility of the response for this book.
  • The 'Why Match' and 'Gap' explanations are excellent, providing thorough justification for its selection and a helpful caveat regarding its content.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Crucially, ensure that all fundamental metadata fields, especially Author and Publishing Date, are consistently present and complete for every book suggested.
  • If information is unavailable, it should be explicitly stated (e.g., 'Author: Not available') rather than omitted entirely.

================================================================================

SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
----------------------------------------
• The overall response provides a mix of direct and indirect book suggestions for the query 'Suggest 3 books for children.'
• Book 2 ('A Christmas Carol') is an excellent and direct match, with complete and well-justified information.
• Book 3 ('A Series of Unfortunate Events') is a good direct choice for children, but critically lacks essential metadata (Author, Publishing Date) in the provided analysis.
• Book 1 ('A+ Parenting') is an indirect match; it's a parenting guide about children's books rather than a book *for* children, which significantly deviates from the query's direct intent, despite the 'Gap' explanation acknowledging this.

OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
----------------------------------------
• Prioritize books that directly fulfill the query's intent (e.g., 'books for children' should suggest books a child would read) over indirectly related content.
• Ensure all essential metadata (Author, Publishing Date) is consistently provided and complete for every suggested book. If information is unavailable, explicitly state it.
• Calibrate relevance scores more precisely to reflect the directness of the match to the query, especially for indirect suggestions like 'A+ Parenting'.

CARD CONTENT EXTRACTION SUMMARY
================================
Total Books: 3

BOOK 1:
  Title: A+ Parenting
  Authors: Eva Moskowitz
  Imprint: Harvest
  Relevance Score: 95%
  Why Match Reasons (4):
    1. The book includes recommended books
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It categorizes books by the earliest age
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The book suggests that older children and even adults can profit from reading books
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
    4. It emphasizes the importance of the quality of books
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 4]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 2:
  Title: A Christmas Carol
  Authors: Charles Dickens
  Imprint: HarperFestival
  Relevance Score: 95%
  Why Match Reasons (3):
    1. It is a classic story suitable for children, with an interest age ranging from 6 to 10
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. The book is a coloring activity book
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Classics
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---
BOOK 3:
  Title: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
  Authors: Lemony Snicket
  Imprint: HarperCollins
  Relevance Score: 95%
  Why Match Reasons (4):
    1. The book is categorized under JUVENILE FICTION
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 1]
    2. It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Family / Orphans & Foster Homes
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 2]
    3. The book is also listed under JUVENILE FICTION: Humorous Stories
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 3]
    4. The book has an interest age from 8 to 12 years
       → Citation Type: metadata
       → Highlighted Text: [Requires citation click - Reason 4]
  Highlighted Texts (0):
---

CHAT DATA SUMMARY
================
Total Books: 3

BOOK 1:
  Title: A+ Parenting
  Author: Eva Moskowitz
  Publishing Date: OCT-24-2023
  Imprint: Harvest
  Score: 95%%
  Reasons (4):
    1. The book includes recommended books
    2. It categorizes books by the earliest age
    3. The book suggests that older children and even adults can profit from reading books
    4. It emphasizes the importance of the quality of books
---
BOOK 2:
  Title: A Christmas Carol
  Author: Charles Dickens
  Publishing Date: JUN-08-2010
  Imprint: HarperFestival
  Score: 92%%
  Reasons (3):
    1. It is a classic story suitable for children, with an interest age ranging from 6 to 10
    2. The book is a coloring activity book
    3. It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Classics
---
BOOK 3:
  Title: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
  Author: Lemony Snicket
  Publishing Date: MAR-17-2009
  Imprint: HarperCollins
  Score: 90%%
  Reasons (4):
    1. The book is categorized under JUVENILE FICTION
    2. It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Family / Orphans & Foster Homes
    3. The book is also listed under JUVENILE FICTION: Humorous Stories
    4. The book has an interest age from 8 to 12 years
---

BOOK TITLES VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 3 | PASSED: 3 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "A+ Parenting"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: A+ Parenting
  Expected: A+ Parenting
---
BOOK: "A Christmas Carol"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: A Christmas Carol
  Expected: A Christmas Carol
---
BOOK: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
  Expected: A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning
---

AUTHORS VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 3 | PASSED: 3 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "A+ Parenting"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Eva Moskowitz
  Expected: Eva Moskowitz
---
BOOK: "A Christmas Carol"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Charles Dickens
  Expected: Charles Dickens
---
BOOK: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: Lemony Snicket
  Expected: Lemony Snicket
---

RELEVANCE SCORES VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 3 | PASSED: 3 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "A+ Parenting"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 95
  Expected: 95%
---
BOOK: "A Christmas Carol"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 95
  Expected: 92%
---
BOOK: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Extracted: 95
  Expected: 90%
---

WHY MATCH REASONS VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 3 | PASSED: 3 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "A+ Parenting"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 4/4 reasons
  Extracted: 4 reasons
---
BOOK: "A Christmas Carol"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 3/3 reasons
  Extracted: 3 reasons
---
BOOK: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
  Status: ✅ PASS
  Matched: 4/4 reasons
  Extracted: 4 reasons
---

COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION REPORT
==================================================
TOTAL: 3 | PASSED: 3 | FAILED: 0

BOOK: "A+ Parenting"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "A Christmas Carol"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---
BOOK: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
  Status: ✅ PASS
---

=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification ===
[3:47:43 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[3:47:44 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[3:47:44 PM] ℹ️ Clicking on mode selection dropdown
[3:47:47 PM] ✅ Mode selection dropdown clicked successfully
[3:47:47 PM] ℹ️ Checking visibility of mode: BookGenieQA
[3:47:47 PM] ✅ Mode "BookGenieQA" is visible
[3:47:47 PM] ℹ️ Selecting mode: BookGenieQA
[3:47:47 PM] ✅ Mode "BookGenieQA" selected successfully
[3:47:49 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for mode transition to complete
[3:47:51 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:48:21 PM] ⚠ ⚠Book Genie mode did not loaded
[3:48:21 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:48:21 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[3:48:21 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[3:48:21 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:48:22 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[3:48:22 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:48:22 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[3:48:22 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[3:48:22 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[3:48:22 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[3:48:24 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[3:48:24 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[3:49:19 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[3:49:19 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Checking for "None of the above, just" option...
[3:49:19 PM] ℹ️ ✓ "None of the above, just" option not present - proceeding normally
[3:49:19 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 2869 characters
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Question Type:  Book Metadata — AnalyzedWatch Me WorkLet me connect the dots for you...Retrieving Re...
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26427 characters
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 1. "A+ Parenting" - Score: 95%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 92%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 90%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 92%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ Extracted 3 books from response
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Saving 3 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 3 books to Excel format
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 18.28 KB
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (3 books) for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A+ Parenting" vs expected: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 95% vs expected: 95%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 95% (expected 95%)
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Christmas Carol" vs expected: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 92% vs expected: 92%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 92% (expected 92%)
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ ℹ️ GAP VALIDATION SKIPPED: No gap expected in reference data
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" vs expected: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 90% vs expected: 90%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 90% (expected 90%)
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books passed
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26427 characters
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[3:49:22 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 1. "A+ Parenting" - Score: 95%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 2. "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 92%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📚 3. "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 90%%
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[3:49:22 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 92%
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Found 9 total accordion sections
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. A+ Parenting"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Processing 3 individual book sections
[3:49:22 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:22 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:25 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:25 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:28 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:28 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:28 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:28 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:30 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:30 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A+ Parenting" - 0 citations extracted
[3:49:30 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:30 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:33 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:33 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:36 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:36 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:36 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:36 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:38 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:49:38 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Christmas Carol" - 0 citations extracted
[3:49:38 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:38 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:41 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:41 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:44 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:44 PM] ℹ️ Found 0 citation buttons for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:44 PM] ⚠ No citation buttons found for "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:44 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:45 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:49:45 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - 0 citations extracted
[3:49:45 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 3 books
[3:49:45 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[3:49:45 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[3:49:45 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "A+ Parenting"
[3:49:45 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:49:50 PM] ❌    ❌ "A+ Parenting" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:49:50 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:49:50 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:49:57 PM] ❌    ❌ "A+ Parenting" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:49:57 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:49:57 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:50:04 PM] ❌    ❌ "A+ Parenting" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:04 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:04 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[3:50:04 PM] ❌    ❌ "A+ Parenting" - Reason 4: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:04 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:04 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:50:04 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:50:05 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:05 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:05 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:50:06 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:06 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:06 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:50:07 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Christmas Carol" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:07 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:07 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:50:07 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[3:50:07 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 1: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:07 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:07 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[3:50:07 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:07 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:07 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[3:50:08 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:08 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[3:50:08 PM] ❌    ❌ "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Reason 4: 0% match - FAIL
[3:50:08 PM] ❌       ⚠️  Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[3:50:08 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 0/11 passed (0.0%)
[3:50:08 PM] ❌ 💥 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[3:50:08 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 0/11 reasons passed
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[3:50:08 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 0/11 (0.0%)
[3:50:08 PM] ❌ ❌ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL FAILED - Only 0.0% of reasons match citations (required: 80%)
[3:50:08 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 11 reasons
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 10032
[3:50:08 PM] 📊 Database contains 10032 books
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 10032 >= 10032
[3:50:08 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/3: "A+ Parenting"
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A+ Parenting"
[3:50:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A+ Parenting" → "A+ Parenting"
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/3: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:50:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:50:09 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Christmas Carol" → "A Christmas Carol"
[3:50:09 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/3: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:50:09 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:50:09 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" → "Eve"
[3:50:09 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books found in database
[3:50:09 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[3:50:09 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[3:50:09 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[3:50:09 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[3:50:09 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[3:51:15 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 75%
[3:51:15 PM] 📊 Analyzed 3 books individually
[3:51:15 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response relevance below threshold (75%)
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A+ Parenting" - Score: 65%
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 90% - Author 'Eva Moskowitz' is clearly identified and relevant to the parenting book's content.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - The publishing date 'OCT-24-2023' is recent and appropriate for a parenting guide, suggesting up-to-date advice.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 80% - The explanations accurately describe why this specific book is relevant to the *topic* of children's books (it recommends and categorizes them). However, it does not directly suggest a book *for* children, which is the primary intent of the query.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 80% - The 95% relevance score is high given the book is a parenting guide and not a direct book for children. However, the 'Gap' explanation properly justifies *why* the score is not 100% by clarifying its indirect nature, which is good justification for its *own* given score, even if the score itself is high for the query.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    - Prioritize direct children's books that children would read themselves for this query.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    - If a 'meta' book (like a parenting guide about children's books) is suggested, the relevance score should be significantly lower or the rationale for its inclusion as a 'book for children' needs stronger justification, perhaps by interpreting the query more broadly.
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Christmas Carol" - Score: 95%
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Author 'Charles Dickens' is clearly identified, highly renowned, and relevant for a classic children's adaptation.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 95% - The publishing date 'JUN-08-2010' is appropriate for a modern edition or adaptation of a classic story, ensuring its contemporary availability.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 100% - The explanations are excellent and directly justify the book's suitability: 'classic story suitable for children,' 'interest age 6 to 10,' 'coloring activity book,' and 'JUVENILE FICTION: Classics.' These are strong reasons for a direct match.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 92% relevance score is well-justified by the strong reasons provided. The lack of a 'Gap' explanation further indicates its direct and appropriate fit for the query.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    - No significant improvements are needed for this book selection; it perfectly addresses the query.
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning" - Score: 70%
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Author information is entirely missing from the provided analysis text for this book.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is entirely missing from the provided analysis text for this book.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are strong and directly justify its suitability: categorized under 'JUVENILE FICTION' (including specific sub-genres) and having an 'interest age from 8 to 12 years.' These are clear indicators for children's literature.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 90% relevance score is appropriately justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which acknowledges elements of 'horror' and 'nefarious plots' that might not suit all children. This demonstrates a nuanced understanding of children's literature suitability.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    - Crucially, ensure that all fundamental metadata fields, especially Author and Publishing Date, are consistently present and complete for every book suggested.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    - If information is unavailable, it should be explicitly stated (e.g., 'Author: Not available') rather than omitted entirely.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    • The overall response provides a mix of direct and indirect book suggestions for the query 'Suggest 3 books for children.'
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    • Book 2 ('A Christmas Carol') is an excellent and direct match, with complete and well-justified information.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    • Book 3 ('A Series of Unfortunate Events') is a good direct choice for children, but critically lacks essential metadata (Author, Publishing Date) in the provided analysis.
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️    • Book 1 ('A+ Parenting') is an indirect match; it's a parenting guide about children's books rather than a book *for* children, which significantly deviates from the query's direct intent, despite the 'Gap' explanation acknowledging this.
[3:51:15 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI AI VALIDATION FAILED: 75% relevance score (required: 80%)
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ Continuing execution due to soft assertion...
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 🔍 CHECKING FOR BOOK CARDS
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for book cards to be visible
[3:51:15 PM] ✅ ✅ Found 3 book cards
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 📖 EXTRACTING DETAILED CARD CONTENT
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ Locating all book card containers
[3:51:15 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 book cards
[3:51:15 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 1/3
[3:51:16 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 1
[3:51:16 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 1
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:51:18 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:51:18 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 1 (after clicking citations)
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️ Card 1 HTML length: 14544 chars
[3:51:18 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 1 content extracted: "A+ Parenting"
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Eva Moskowitz
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: Harvest
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 95
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 4
[3:51:18 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:18 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 2/3
[3:51:19 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 2
[3:51:19 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 2
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:51:21 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:51:21 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 2 (after clicking citations)
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️ Card 2 HTML length: 10381 chars
[3:51:21 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 2 content extracted: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Charles Dickens
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: HarperFestival
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 95
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 3
[3:51:21 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:21 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK CARD 3/3
[3:51:22 PM] ℹ️ Opening "Why this book is the match" section for card 3
[3:51:22 PM] ℹ️ Button state: data-state="closed", aria-expanded="false"
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Clicking citation buttons to reveal highlighted text for card 3
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ 🔍 Looking for citation buttons to extract highlighted text...
[3:51:24 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ No citation buttons found using the specified locator
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ 🎯 Total highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from card 3 (after clicking citations)
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Card 3 HTML length: 11488 chars
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ Book 3 content extracted: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️    - Authors: Lemony Snicket
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️    - Imprint: HarperCollins
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️    - Relevance Score: 95
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️    - Reasons found: 4
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️    - Highlighted texts extracted: 0
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted content from 3/3 book cards
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 💬 EXTRACTING EXPECTED DATA FROM CHAT PANEL
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Locating left-side chat panel
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Verifying all sections are expanded...
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 book sections to expand
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section 1
[3:51:24 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ Error expanding chat sections: Error: locator.click: Error: strict mode violation: locator('.accordion').first().locator('details:has-text("Book Title:")').first().locator('summary:has(span.truncate):not(:has-text("Why this book is the"))') resolved to 2 elements:
    1) 
…
 aka locator('summary').filter({ hasText: 'A+ Parenting' })
    2) 
…
 aka locator('summary').filter({ hasText: 'The Gap' }).first()

Call log:
  - waiting for locator('.accordion').first().locator('details:has-text("Book Title:")').first().locator('summary:has(span.truncate):not(:has-text("Why this book is the"))')

[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from chat panel
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Chat HTML content extracted - Length: 14512 characters
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract expected book data using BookExtractor
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "A+ Parenting"
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book includes recommended books..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It categorizes books by the earliest age..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The book suggests that older children and even adults can profit from reading bo..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 4: "It emphasizes the importance of the quality of books..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "A Christmas Carol"
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "It is a classic story suitable for children, with an interest age ranging from 6..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "The book is a coloring activity book..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Classics..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Extracting complete reasons for: "A Series of Unfortunate Events #1: The Bad Beginning"
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 reasons from whyMatch field
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 1: "The book is categorized under JUVENILE FICTION..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 2: "It falls under the genre of JUVENILE FICTION: Family / Orphans & Foster Home..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 3: "The book is also listed under JUVENILE FICTION: Humorous Stories..."
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Reason 4: "The book has an interest age from 8 to 12 years..."
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED EXPECTED DATA FROM CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 books in chat panel
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK TITLES AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL BOOK TITLES VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 👥 VALIDATING AUTHORS AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL AUTHORS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 📊 VALIDATING RELEVANCE SCORES AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL RELEVANCE SCORES VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING WHY MATCH REASONS AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ ✅ ALL WHY MATCH REASONS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] 📋 🏆 COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATION AGAINST CHAT
[3:51:24 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL COMPREHENSIVE VALIDATIONS PASSED AGAINST CHAT
=== END LOGS ===